Session 9 - GATT in International Trade Law

on Selasa, 28 Mei 2013

Course       : Law in International Business
Lecturer     : Dr. Shidarta, S.H., M.Hum.
Date           : 14  May 2013 (Session 9)

Topic         : GATT in International Trade Law

Method      : GSLC


GATT is one of the sources of law in regulating inter-State trade policy and the rules of trade between businessmen.

GATT was formed in 1947 and brought two changes:
1. GATT and the WTO to take over the role of making it as one attachment WTO rules.
2. GATT principles to frame rules for new fields in the WTO agreements. For example GATS, TRIMS, TRIPS.

Purpose of establishing the GATT: Creating a climate of international trade are obvious to the business community and sustainable trade liberalization, trade jobs and a healthy climate.

The main objective of GATT:
1)  Improving the living conditions of human beings
2) Increase employment opportunities
3) Increase the utilization of the world’s natural resources
4) Increase the production & exchange of goods

The main function of GATT:
1. A set of regulations governing multilateral trade transactions undertaken by GATT member countries.
2. As a forum for trade negotiations and trade liberalization.
3. Keeping the rules clear for the opening of the national market.

Background of GATT:
1.    Formed as a temporary container after the World War two.
2.    The need was felt true multilateral institutions
3.    To prevent a recurrence of the practice in the 1930s protectionism.

Organizational systems of GATT:
1.    A mechanism of decision-making in the WTO is by consensus.
2.     Voting with one country, one vote to win a majority.

Organizational structures of GATT:
1.    Ministerial Conference (Highest decision-making)
2.    General Council (Daily Executive shall consist of representatives of the member)
3.    Council for Trade in Goods (Implementation of agreements in the field of goods)
4.    Council for Trade in Services (Implementation of agreements in the field of service)
5.    Council for Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property
6.    Dispute Settlementy Body (Settlement of disputes between members of the forum)

Terms of trade in GATT:
1.    38th article.
2.    Tokyo round of negotiations produced is anti-dumping regulations, subsidies and non-tariff provisions or sectoral issues.
3.    Multifibre arrangements.

Principles of GATT:
1.    Most favored nation (Giving other countries the same treatment)
2.    National treatment (Must be the same as any imported products in the country)
3.    Prohibition of quantitative restrictions (The export/import can be in any form)
4.    Protection through tariff (Protection of domestic industry through tariff)
5.    Reciprocal (Mutually beneficial to both parties)
6.    Specially for countries that are still developing (Help economic growth)

Work of the Goods Council:
The Goods Council is the one handling the operation of the GATT Agreement & the committees’ duties, working groups & working parties on sectors of activity covered by the Agreement. Which are:

1.    Agriculture
2.    Market access for goods
3.    Sanitary & phytosanitary measures
4.    Subsidies & countervailing measure
5.    Anti-dumping
6.    Customs valuation
7.    Rules of origin
8.    Import licensing
9.    Investment
10.  Safeguards
11.  State trading enterprises
12.  Information technology agreement

Examples of current GATT events:
·         December 2010 – The European Union expresses support for Russia’s bid to join the WTO after Moscow agreed to cut timber export tariffs & rail freight fees. Russia is the only major economy outside the WTO. China says it plans to appeal against WTO ruling that the US was entitled to impose extra duties on China tyre imports.
·         December 2011 – Russia finally joins the WTO after 18 years negotiating its membership. Switzerland brokered a deal to persuade Georgia to lift its veto, which it had imposed after the 2008 Russo-Georgian war. WTO agrees terms for Samoa & Montenegro to join in 2012.
·         January 2012 – The WTO rejects China’s appeal against a ruling that it broke free trade rules by imposing quotas & taxes on exports of key materials.

Reference:

Conclusion:
GATT is more focused on protecting individual rights & it is also an international agreement that contains different set of economic goals than other international agreement organizations have established. GATT also contains precise obligations to manage trade relations & it has also resolved a lot conflicts between the contracting parties.




Session 8 - Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights

on Selasa, 14 Mei 2013

Course             : Law in International Business
Lecturer           : Dr. Shidarta, S.H., M.Hum.
Date                : 7 May 2013 (Session 8)
Topic               : Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPs)

Method            : F2F (Face to face)


 
Background  :
·         TRIPs = Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights
·         The birth of the TRIPs agreement in the Uruguay Round [GATT], in essence, is the impact intrenasional trading conditions increasingly widespread and knows no national boundaries.
·         State who first proposed the birth of TRIPs is the United States, in anticipation of the opinion that the WIPO [World Intellectual Property Organization] under the UN, is not capable of protecting IPRs in the international market which will result in a negative trade.
The World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) is one of the 17 specialized agencies of the United Nations. WIPO was created in 1967 "to encourage creative activity, to promote the protection of intellectual property throughout the world.


What is WIPO?

WIPO mission is to promote innovation and creativity for the economic, social and cultural development of all countries, through a balanced and effective international intellectual property system.
WIPO promote the development and use of the international IP system through:
  • Services - WIPO run systems which make it easier to obtain protection internationally for patents, trademarks, designs and appellations of origin; and to resolve IP disputes.
  • Law - WIPO help develop the international legal IP framework in line with society’s evolving needs.
  • Infrastructure - WIPO build collaborative networks and technical platforms to share knowledge and simplify IP transactions, including free databases and tools for exchanging information.
  • Development - WIPO build capacity in the use of IP to support economic development.
WIPO also work with our member states and stakeholders to improve understanding and respect for IP worldwide. WIPO provide economic analysis and statistics. And WIPO contribute IP-based solutions to help tackle global challenges .

WIPO weaknesses are:

1.      WIPO is an organization where members are limited [not much], so that the WIPO provisions can not be enforced against non-members of WIPO.
2.      WIPO does not have a mechanism to resolve and punish any violation of IPR.
3.      Besides that WIPO could no longer adapt changes in the structure of international trade and changes in the level of technological invasion.

The purpose of TRIPs :
ü  Increased protection of IPR of products traded
ü  Ensure the implementation of the IPR procedures that do not impede trade
ü  Formulate the rules and discipline of the implementation of the protection of IPR
ü  Develop the principles, rules and mechanisms for international cooperation to deal with trafficking counterfeit goods or piracy results on IPR
TRIPs Principles :
o   Free to Determine
o   Intellectual Property Convention 
o   National Treatment
o   Most-Favored-Nation-Treatment
o   Exhaustion
The requirements of TRIPS :
TRIPS requires member states to provide strong protection for intellectual property rights. For example, under TRIPS:
  • Copyright terms must extend at least 50 years, unless based on the life of the author. 
  • Copyright must be granted automatically, and not based upon any "formality," such as registrations, as specified in the Berne Convention.
  • Computer programs must be regarded as "literary works" under copyright law and receive the same terms of protection.
  • National exceptions to copyright (such as "fair use" in the United States) are constrained by the Berne three-step test
  • Patents must be granted for "inventions" in all "fields of technology" provided they meet all other patentability requirements (although exceptions for certain public interests are allowed and must be enforceable for at least 20 years.
  • Exceptions to exclusive rights must be limited, provided that a normal exploitation of the work and normal exploitation of the patent is not in conflict.
  • No unreasonable prejudice to the legitimate interests of the right holders of computer programs and patents is allowed.
  • Legitimate interests of third parties have to be taken into account by patent rights.
  • In each state, intellectual property laws may not offer any benefits to local citizens which are not available to citizens of other TRIPS signatories under the principle of national treatment. TRIPS also has a most favored nation clause.
Many of the TRIPS provisions on copyright were copied from the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works and many of its trademark and patent provisions were modeled on the Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property.

Intellectual property rights
Property arising and birth because of intelectual capabilities  [or if brain think] human

Right to enjoy the economics result of an  intellectual human creativity without interference from other parties.

Intellectual property rights :

ü  Copyright and Related Rights
ü  Industrial Property :
§  Patent
§  Trademark
§  Geographical Indication
§  Industrial Design
§  Layout Design of Integrated Circuit
§  Trade Secret
§  Plant Variety
License : permission granted by the rights holder [Copyright, Trade Secret, Industrial Design, Layout Designs of Integrated Circuits, Patents] to another party through an agreement based on the granting of rights [not transfer the rights] to enjoy the economic benefits of the Copyrights, Trade Secrets , Industrial Designs, Layout Designs of Integrated Circuits, Patents are granted a protection for a specified period and certain terms.
A licensor may grant a license under intellectual property laws to authorise a use (such as copying software or using a (patented) invention) to a licensee, sparing the licensee from a claim of infringement brought by the licensor. A license under intellectual property commonly has several components beyond the grant itself, including a term, territory, renewal provisions, and other limitations deemed vital to the licensor.



Reflection :
TRIPs have many requirement,purpose and principle. WIPO is one of TRIPs organization. From this material we can conclude that in Law of International Trade we need to consider about the intelectual property right and license. There are many step and requirement to get our own right. There are a complicated step in Indonesia to get our own property right, it need 48 days only to get a patent. Meanwhile in another country like singapure they are only have 3 days to make a patent. So we need to work hard to make our inovation get the intellectual property rights.
Reference :
PowerPoint from binus maya by Agus Riyanto, SH, LL.M

Session 7 - United Nation Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods(CISG)

on Senin, 13 Mei 2013

Course             : Law in International Business
Lecturer           : Dr. Shidarta, S.H., M.Hum.
Date                : 16 April 2013 (Session 7)
Topic               : United Nation Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods(CISG)
Method            : F2F (Face to face)

United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) is s a treaty that is a uniform international sales law. CISG 1980 is a work of the United Nations Commission on international trade (UNCITRAL) as an effort to harmonizing trade law between countries which entered into force on 1 January 1988.

Reservations
  1. Signer countries may make a reservation
  2. Exclude certain parts of the convention
  3. Exclude validity on one or some states ( for federal states )
  4. International contract CISG allow a verbal contract ( oral contract of sale )
The purpose of CISG is preparing or promoting the adoption of new international conventions, model laws and uniform laws, and promoting the codification and wider acceptance of international trade terms, provisions, customs and practices, in cooperation with appropriate organizations operating in this field.

Validity of CISG

Requirement:
·         The parties ( the sale ) are in different countries
·         The country become a participant of CISG convention
·         In validity contract of CISG not obstructed by choice of law

Modifications in the contract

The parties can avoid modification by making the clause “Four Corner Clause”
the scope of the CISG:
·
         Based on the nature of transaction :
1.      Consumer Contract
2.      Sales by Auction
3.      On execution

·         Based on the nature of good :
1.      Sale of securities
2.      Sale of ship and planes
3.      Sale of electricity

Fundamental breach of contract

A brench of contract is fundamental if the damage it causes to the other party is so substantial that he is entitled to expect under the contract.

The requirement of the contract agreement :
-          coercion
-          Fraud
-          misguidance
-          Undue Influence

CISG Binding Power

CISG actually has no force of law, CISG’s article 95 said that “any state may declare when delivered up the instrument of ratification… that the state was not committed themselves to article 1 paragraph ( 1 ) ( b ) this convention.” Article 6 CISG allow parties override the validity of CISG either whole or in part. Thus, the parties could design a clause option of law sets law as options, a country but ignoring CISG as a whole.

Rights and Obligations of The Seller

Provisions CISG only regulate specifically about obligations of the parties as dictated in chapter II about liability the seller and chapter III in CISG that enumerates about liability buyer. In reciprocal can be inferred that an obligation the seller is the right of the buyers similarly contrarily.

Conclusion :

Through these lessons, we could understand that CISG is a work made by United Nation to harmonize law of trade between countries. We are also can know and understand the requirements, validity, scope, exception and others in CISG.

Reference :

Wikipedia
UNCITRAL Website
aafandia.wordpress.com